I'm trying to decide between these three cars. The corolla is used with 25k miles selling for $13,600 from Hertz. The yaris is inexpensive with great gas mileage. I don't know if I should just buy a new car, or buy the used corolla, which is the cheapest. Ugh.

The Toyota Yaris has among the lowest customer satisfaction ratings (according to Consumer Reports) of any car sold in the USA. I would not consider it if I were you.