Both 2004, 30k miles and Toyota is listed at 16,500 the BMW at 17,500.

What should I realisticly pay and what would be the best bet.

Should it be a worry that the MR2 is not made anymore or would that keep the value up.
Wait they are both 2003.

The KBB on the BMW is 22,000
The KBB on the MR2 is 17,000